Buy Buy Baby draws sale interest in Bed Bath & Beyond bankruptcy, one bidder looks to save stores
Bed Bath & Beyond is expected to be dissolved after the failed retailer declared bankruptcy, but the company’s crown jewel — Buy Buy Baby — may live to see another day.
The baby gear retailer is drawing interest from at least two bidders as its parent company, Bed Bath & Beyond, works to auction off its assets and keep some form of its business alive, CNBC has learned.
The interested parties include an unknown bidder, who would purchase the banner as a going concern and keep about 75% of stores open, according to correspondence obtained by CNBC. The other interested bidder is Babylist, a direct-to-consumer baby registry website that wants to buy its trademark and domain, that company’s CEO, Natalie Gordon, confirmed to CNBC.
So far, it doesn’t appear as if there’s any interest in buying the Bed Bath banner and keeping its stores open, but some bidders are interested in buying its digital assets, a person familiar with the matter told CNBC.
It’s not clear how much the unknown bidder is offering to purchase Buy Buy Baby, but it was seeking an additional $50 million in capital to shore up its proposal, according to the correspondence. That figure offers the first clue into how much bidders are willing to pay to snap up the pieces of Bed Bath’s fallen business.
The valuation of the company and its intellectual property is unclear. In its most recent quarterly securities filing, Bed Bath noted the intangible value of trade names and trademarks was just $13.4 million.
As of late November, Bed Bath & Beyond had about $4.4 billion in assets and $5.2 billion in debts, court filings show.
Gordon declined to share the number Babylist offered for Buy Buy’s trademark and domain.
Who are the bidders?
Ankura Capital Advisors, an investment banking firm, is advising the unnamed bidder and said in a May 16 email to its distribution list that the party is seeking a financial partner “to help lead the purchase of Buybuy Baby out of the BBBY bankruptcy.”
The client was seeking the additional $50 million in capital alongside its current financial sponsor to support a stalking horse bid on the asset, according to the correspondence, which was seen by CNBC. A stalking horse bid is an offer on the assets of a bankrupt company that, if accepted, sets a price floor for future bids.
The mystery bidder, who was not named in the documents seen by CNBC, is an “independent operator with several successful, complimentary retail chains in their portfolio,” according to the message.
“They are open to various structures for the investment, from equity to preferred equity and other forms of junior capital,” the message reads. “They have committed over 400 hours in extensive diligence already and have the team and experience to operate the stores as a going concern.”
In the email, Ankura notes that Buy Buy Baby had about $90 million in inventory at the time of the bankruptcy filing and had been liquidating about $7.5 million weekly at the time the message was sent.
Babylist showroom floor
Babylist bills itself as a destination for all things baby. It saw $290 million in revenue in 2022, says it’s profitable and counts over a million new parent sign-ups each year. The company said it considered putting in a bid to buy the entire chain, including its stores, but it ultimately decided it didn’t fit into its overall strategic plan.
Babylist says it started out as a destination for the modern parent who is tired of the same old pink and blue landscapes but that it’s now working to expand its audience to all members of the proverbial village, including grandparents.
That’s where Buy Buy Baby — and its long-held name recognition — would come in.
If Babylist’s bid to acquire the banner’s trademark and domain were to be accepted, people who search for Buy Buy Baby and try to access the website would be redirected to Babylist, Gordon explained.
“We have tremendous trust with new and expecting parents but Buy Buy Baby is much better known with kind of that older generation,” she said. “So as we’re expanding to the whole family as an audience, we really think it can jumpstart us in that way.”
Gordon said the company opted out of putting in an offer for Buy Buy Baby’s registry assets because of how quickly they can become stale.
Plus, the company already appears to be taking share from Buy Buy Baby. Since Bed Bath’s bankruptcy was announced, Babylist has had nearly 200,000 new sign-ups, which is a higher number of new customers than the company usually sees in that period of time, it said.
Following the bankruptcy of Babies ‘R’ Us and the potential liquidation of Buy Buy Baby, there are few major retailers families can turn to that cater exclusively to the infant category. For registries, their options include Target, Amazon and Babylist, among others.
Babylist doesn’t operate any traditional brick-and-mortar locations but plans to open its first showroom in Beverly Hills, California, this summer.
The crown jewel of Bed Bath & Beyond
This is not the first time Buy Buy Baby has seen sale interest. The banner reportedly drew interest from potential buyers in 2022. It also caught the attention of activist investor Ryan Cohen, co-founder of Chewy and chair of GameStop, who last March pointed to the baby gear banner as one of the most valuable pieces of the company, arguing it could be worth several billion dollars.
At the time, Cohen pushed for a spinoff or sale.
Buy Buy Baby has remained a bright spot in Bed Bath & Beyond’s otherwise dismal earnings reports in recent years.
A Buy Buy Baby store in the Brooklyn borough of New York, US, on Monday, Feb. 6, 2023.
Stephanie Keith | Bloomberg | Getty Images
In Bed Bath’s fiscal 2021 holiday quarter, same-store sales for Bed Bath & Beyond stores declined 15% — but Buy Buy Baby’s same-store sales grew by low single digits.
And more recently, during Bed Bath’s fiscal third quarter of 2022, which ended Nov. 26, sales declines were reported across the company, but Buy Buy Baby’s revenue declines outperformed Bed Bath’s. During the quarter, comparable sales at the Bed Bath banner declined 34%, while at Buy Buy Baby, they declined in the low 20% range, the company said at the time.
When Bed Bath & Beyond locations were shuttering across the country as part of the company’s efforts to stop the financial bleeding, it opened more Buy Buy Baby locations in the hopes the stores would boost sales.
As of late April, 120 of the stores were still open, alongside 360 of Bed Bath’s namesake stores, the company said previously.
Bed Bath & Beyond’s bankruptcy auction has been delayed twice, which could indicate the company is still trying to drum up interest for its assets.
In the months before Bed Bath declared bankruptcy, CNBC reported the company was courting prospective buyers and lenders that would be willing to take on the company and keep its doors open. At the time, the potential buyers included private equity firm Sycamore Partners, which was particularly interested in Buy Buy Baby, and Authentic Brands, which has frequented many bankruptcy-run sales for retailers such as Forever 21.
In the end, the process proved unsuccessful and produced “limited interest in a viable proposal to acquire the Debtors’ assets,” according to court records filed in the company’s bankruptcy case in April.
Still, in those filings, the company said it was confident it could offload its names and stores and said it planned to market the business to avoid outright liquidation.
“While the commencement of a full chain wind-down is necessitated by economic realities, Bed Bath & Beyond has and will continue to market their businesses as a going-concern, including the buybuy Baby business,” the company’s chief financial officer and chief restructuring officer Holly Etlin wrote in a declaration to New Jersey’s bankruptcy court at the time.
In the filings, the company confirmed CNBC’s prior reporting and said more than 100 potential investors had been engaged by Bed Bath’s advisors. Prospective bidders were asked if they were interested in buying the business as a going concern or providing Chapter 11 financing.
The company had been hoping a buyer would be willing to purchase either Bed Bath & Beyond or Buy Buy Baby as standalone businesses, buy the brands’ intellectual property and perhaps take on a few of their better performing stores.
“Bed Bath & Beyond has pulled off long shot transactions several times in the last six months, so nobody should think Bed Bath & Beyond will not be able to do so again. To the contrary, Bed Bath & Beyond and its professionals will make every effort to salvage all or a portion of operations for the benefit of all stakeholders,” Etlin added in the filings.
Further delays in the auction process could signal willingness on Bed Bath’s part to entertain the offer from the unknown bidder, provided the bidder can find more capital.
Ankura declined to comment on the matter. Bed Bath & Beyond didn’t respond to a request for comment.
Bed Bath previously told CNBC the auction had been delayed so it could have “more time to ensure the most value-maximizing transaction is achieved.”
Stalking horse bids are now due on June 8 at 5 p.m., and final bids are now due on June 14. An auction, if necessary, is scheduled for June 16.
— CNBC’s Lillian Rizzo contributed to this report.